AIDS activists say PEPFAR?s strategy to prevent the spread of HIV places a disproportionate and ?unrealistic? emphasis on its ?Abstinence? and ?Be Faithful? ? the so-called A and B ? components, and significantly less on its C aspect ? Condoms.

?PEPFAR looks at A and B only, and the C in the PEPFAR approach is the last thing that you can ever think about,? says Uganda?s Beatrice Were, who?s HIV-positive herself.

Confusion Surrounds Condom Policies Of US AIDS Plan

?The United States government has certainly promoted views which one could argue come from a religious point of view instead of a scientific point of view, around the prevention of HIV,? comments Nathan Geffen, of South Africa?s Treatment Action Campaign.

Confusion Surrounds Condom Policies Of US AIDS Plan

Warren Buckingham, who heads the PEPFAR program in Kenya, says many activists accuse the Plan?s administrators of being ?out of touch? with what?s happening ?on the ground? - but often, he claims, it?s the other way around.

Confusion Surrounds Condom Policies Of US AIDS Plan

?I think the deliberate misinformation about what can and cannot be done in terms of prevention (by PEPFAR) has been a real challenge for us. And most of that has unfortunately come from the activist community. Four years on, I regularly work with community groups who have been told (by activists): ?You know, if you accept PEPFAR programs, you can?t talk about condoms; you can only talk about abstinence.? And that is absolutely false information and it is not coming from us.?

Buckingham alleges ?intentional and unfortunate distortion? about PEPFAR?s policy on condoms.

?It has never been A or B or C. It has always been A and B and C,? he stresses.

This isn?t what?s happening ?on the ground? in Africa, says Dr. Paul Zeitz, of the Global Aids Alliance in Washington.

?I was in Zambia a few weeks ago, and I visited a (PEPFAR) counseling and testing program, where a person comes in who is obviously sexually active, is trying to get their (HIV) status ? whether they?re positive or negative ? and is given no information about condoms or sexual prevention. That?s outrageous. That?s bad public health, and that should no longer be acceptable to people in those countries,? he states.

Marina Guevara, a journalist who?s participated in an extensive investigation into PEPFAR in Africa on behalf of the Washington-based Center for Public Integrity, says her research reveals that condom education is an area ?not as well covered in many PEPFAR programs as the AB message? is.

But Dr. Tom Kenyon, a senior PEPFAR official in the US State Department?s Office of the Global Coordinator on HIV/AIDS in Washington, insists: ?We don?t ever say: Abstinence instead of condoms.?

Were isn?t convinced: ?PEPFAR is compromising scientific approaches to AIDS, which show that condoms are far better tools in preventing HIV/AIDS than instructing people not to have sex, or to be faithful. PEPFAR is wasting money on A and B projects that don?t work. That money could be better used - to buy medicine, for example, and to tell young people about condoms,? she says.

Kenyon says PEPFAR officers are ?all scientists? and are therefore in a better position to judge the efficacy of health programs than most AIDS activists are. And although condoms offer ?very good? protection against HIV, he says, science has also shown that they aren?t one hundred per cent effective. Nevertheless, Kenyon argues that PEPFAR places a ?high premium? on condom use in Africa.

?We?re major supporters of condom utilization. Over the past three and a half years, we?ve purchased and distributed over half-a-billion condoms for the countries that we?re supporting.?

But what particularly angers activists about PEPFAR is the Plan?s regulation that essentially prevents organizations that receive its money from giving condom education to people younger than 14 years of age.

?We are expected to focus with children under the age of 14 on A and B. But we have every bit of permission?. to talk with anyone over the age of 14 about correct and consistent use of condoms,? Buckingham clarifies.

?Not good enough,? says Were. ?What about all the little girls all over Africa who, because they don?t have anything to eat, sell their bodies for food? Shouldn?t they also be taught that condoms protect them against infection

?It?s absolutely essential that children in Africa are taught at primary school level about condoms, so that they?re best able to protect themselves from HIV if and when they become sexually active,? Zeitz says.

Guevara says her research indicates that the Plan?s ?rigid rules? are impacting ?very negatively? on the continent?s response to the AIDS pandemic.