The Sarah Records' catalogue consists of around a hundred items, each of which has a catalogue number. The items from Sarah 001 to Sarah 100 are mostly 7 inch singles. Exceptions are: Sarah 3, 70 which are flexi discs Sarah 4, 14, 32 and 70, which are fanzines Sarah 38, a 10" EP Sarah 50, a board game Sarah 42 and 57, 12" singles Sarah 100, the There And Back Again Lane compilation (a CD album).
Some of the 7" singles were additionally available on CD. There are also seven 10 inch albums (Sarah 401 to 407) and 22 LPs (Sarah 601 to 622), some or all of which were also released on compact disc.