Treatise on the Sacraments

Question. 77 - OF THE ACCIDENTS WHICH REMAIN IN THIS SACRAMENT (EIGHT ARTICLES)

We must now consider the accidents which remain in this sacrament; under which head there are eight points of inquiry:

Summa Theologiae/Third Part/Question 77

(1) Whether the accidents which remain are without a subject?

Summa Theologiae/Third Part/Question 77

(2) Whether dimensive quantity is the subject of the other accidents?

Summa Theologiae/Third Part/Question 77

(3) Whether such accidents can affect an extrinsic body?

(4) Whether they can be corrupted?

(5) Whether anything can be generated from them?

(6) Whether they can nourish?

(7) Of the breaking of the consecrated bread?

(8) Whether anything can be mixed with the consecrated wine?

Art. 1 - Whether the accidents remain in this sacrament without a subject?

Objection 1: It seems that the accidents do not remain in this

sacrament without a subject, because there ought not to be anything

disorderly or deceitful in this sacrament of truth. But for accidents

to be without a subject is contrary to the order which God established

in nature; and furthermore it seems to savor of deceit, since accidents

are naturally the signs of the nature of the subject. Therefore the

accidents are not without a subject in this sacrament.

Objection 2: Further, not even by miracle can the definition of a thing

be severed from it, or the definition of another thing be applied to

it; for instance, that, while man remains a man, he can be an

irrational animal. For it would follow that contradictories can exist

at the one time: for the "definition of a thing is what its name

expresses," as is said in Metaph. iv. But it belongs to the definition

of an accident for it to be in a subject, while the definition of

substance is that it must subsist of itself, and not in another. Therefore it cannot come to pass, even by miracle, that the accidents exist without a subject in this sacrament.

Objection 3: Further, an accident is individuated by its subject. If

therefore the accidents remain in this sacrament without a subject, they will not be individual, but general, which is clearly false, because thus they would not be sensible, but merely intelligible.

Objection 4: Further, the accidents after the consecration of this

sacrament do not obtain any composition. But before the consecration

they were not composed either of matter and form, nor of existence [quo

est] and essence [quod est]. Therefore, even after consecration they

are not composite in either of these ways. But this is unreasonable, for thus they would be simpler than angels, whereas at the same time these accidents are perceptible to the senses. Therefore, in this sacrament the accidents do not remain without a subject.

On the contrary, Gregory says in an Easter Homily (Lanfranc, De Corp. et Sang. Dom. xx) that "the sacramental species are the names of those things which were there before, namely, of the bread and wine." Therefore since the substance of the bread and the wine does not remain, it seems that these species remain without a subject.

I answer that, The species of the bread and wine, which are perceived

by our senses to remain in this sacrament after consecration, are not

subjected in the substance of the bread and wine, for that does not

remain, as stated above ([4566]Q[75], A[2]); nor in the substantial

form, for that does not remain ([4567]Q[75], A[6]), and if it did

remain, "it could not be a subject," as Boethius declares (De Trin. i). Furthermore it is manifest that these accidents are not subjected in the substance of Christ's body and blood, because the substance of the human body cannot in any way be affected by such accidents; nor is it possible for Christ's glorious and impassible body to be altered so as to receive these qualities.