A minor objection to the theory is, that it would make, not the hero, but the lady, the real centre of the story, which is certainly not the case. But, as we shall see, the tale in its original form is far older than Chrétien, _and could by no possibility have been invented at so late a date as Professor Foerster suggests_.
_Yvain_, as one of Arthur's knights, is of a date considerably anterior to Chrétien. We find him in Wace's _Brut_, as a valiant hero, on whom Arthur, after the death of Aguisel, bestows the crown of Scotland.[74] Now, Professor Foerster himself states, and I think the great majority of scholars will fully agree with him, that neither _Erec_, _Yvain_, nor _Perceval_ were _originally_ Arthurian heroes, and undoubtedly their connection with Arthur's court was of the slightest. If their connection with Arthur marks a secondary stage in the story, and _Yvain_ in the _Brut_ is already an Arthurian knight, it is pretty obvious that the original tale connected with him, by virtue of which he was admitted into the magic circle of Arthurian romance, must be older even than Wace; in other words, he must have been the hero of a popular adventure upwards of thirty years, at least, before Chrétien wrote his poem. And if that original story was not the fountain-story, what was it?
But if we look at the tale aright, I think we shall discover that its essential character is so archaic that it may well be as old as the most exacting criticism can require. What is it but the variant of a _motif_ coeval with the earliest stages of human thought and religious practice--the tale of him '_who slew the slayer, and shall himself be slain_'? The champion who must needs defend his charge single-handed against all comers, and whose victor must perforce take his place; and how old this tale may be, Mr. Frazer has taught us.[75]
This surmise is strengthened by the nature of the challenge; Yvain's pouring the water, which is followed by a storm, is a simple piece of sympathetic magic--of rain-making, and, as such, is practised even to-day by savages in different parts of the world. Such a story must, by its very nature, have been originally _un_localised, even as it cannot be dated; it could be postulated of _any_ place, it might be practised everywhere--it belongs just as much, and just as little, to South Africa in the present day as to the wood of Broceliande in the twelfth century.