But in face of the passage quoted by M. Paulin Paris, in his translation of the prose _Lancelot_, probably few will contend that the story of _Perceval_ was not anterior to, and well-known by the compiler of, the first mentioned romance. _Et le grant conte de Lancelot convient repairier en la fin à Perceval qui est chiés et la fin de tos les contes ès autres chevaliers. Et tout sont branches de lui, qu'il acheva la grant queste. Et li contes Perceval meismes est une branche del haut conte del Graal qui est chiés de tos les contes._[108]

We should note here that when this particular passage was written the writer evidently knew nothing of Galahad as the Grail Winner, though he knew the _Lancelot_ story in an advanced stage. We shall have occasion to refer to this later on.

The Legend of Sir Lancelot du Lac — Part 57

In the account of Lancelot's first appearance at court we find an incident which appears to connect the story with a cycle of poems bearing a curious resemblance to the _Perceval_ cycle--the _Bel Inconnu_ poems. Immediately after the hero has received knighthood, as they sit at meat in the hall, a messenger arrives, sent by the 'Dame de Nohan,'[109] asking for a champion to aid her against the King of Northumberland. Lancelot (whose name we must remember is not yet revealed, and who is referred to by the compiler as _Le Beau Varlet_) at once requests that the adventure be given to him, and, though Arthur demurs on account of his youth and inexperience, insists that he has a right to it, as the first boon he has claimed since he was knighted.

The Legend of Sir Lancelot du Lac — Part 57

It is under precisely similar circumstances that the hero of the _Bel Inconnu_ stories undertakes his first adventure.

The Legend of Sir Lancelot du Lac — Part 57

Others have been struck by this resemblance, and M. Philipot, in his review of Dr. Schofield's _Studies on the Libeaus Desconus_,[110] maintains that the _Lancelot_ story (more particularly in the version known to Ulrich von Zatzikhoven) is the elder of the two, and the source of the parallel adventure of the _Bel Inconnu_ group.

With this view I cannot agree. I have elsewhere[111] given reasons for holding the true order of the _Enfances_ to be as follows, _Perceval_, _Le Bel Inconnu_, _Lancelot_, and to this view I adhere. We must remember that the French original of the _Lanzelet_ must in any case be prior to 1194; how much earlier we have no means of deciding, but the _Lanzelet_ has points of contact with both the _Perceval_ (Enfances) and the _Bel Inconnu_ (Fier Baiser) story. Further, the prose _Lancelot_, though differing very widely from Ulrich von Zatzikhoven's poem, yet, as we see, also offers parallels both to _Perceval_ and _Le Bel Inconnu_; such parallels being entirely different from those of the _Lanzelet_. To assert that these stories borrowed from the _Lancelot_ would involve the existence, at an early date, of a fully developed and widely diffused _Lancelot_ legend, a conclusion which the absence of all reference to the hero in the earlier Arthurian romances forbids.