One of the oceanic domains of the North Pacific is the transitional domain, which lies east-west where the West Wind Drift impinges upon the coasts of British Columbia and Washington State. It is precisely in this sector that there was a well-documented "temperature anomaly" in 1957-58. Since an anomaly implies something completely out of the ordinary, I seriously question the appropriateness of the term for an event that may or may not be recurrent (at the time it was a pronounced variation from the oceanographic records accumulated up to that time, but the period had not been a very long one). It is no coincidence that the numbers of albatrosses recorded at Ocean Weather Station "Papa" was higher during this warm-water "anomaly" than subsequently (indeed, an 18-year record of the seabirds recorded at "Papa" also exhibits other interesting fluctuations from the base-line data in certain years).
Recent analyses of sediments from off the coast of California have demonstrated long-term fluctuations in sardine populations extending back at least 1,800 years, with increases lasting 20-150 years and spaced 20-200 years apart. The number of anchovies declined steadily. Yet until now, El Niño events have been treated as anomalies in that region as well as off the coast of Peru. Just as we recognize that different species of fish follow the warm water north on such occasions, we must also recognize the rather distinct seabird species assemblage that is trapped, as it were, in the Gulf of California. Clearly, like the termination point of the West Wind Drift at about the 45-55° parallel, the coast of Baja California and southern California State, from the 25-35° parallel where the California Current begins to swing away from the coast to the west as the North Equatorial Current, is another zone of instability.
I think that it is no accident that the southern limit of several northern species of North Pacific seabirds ends in southeastern Alaska or northern British Columbia, and that the northern limit of the ranges of several other species occurs in Washington State or southern British Columbia. Indeed, the west coast of Vancouver Island is not rich in species, and several of those that exist are not present in great numbers. This is a region of rather more variable conditions than elsewhere, and species evidently find that it is difficult to colonize and it quickly becomes unsuitable again. Since 1940, indeed, there has been a parallel decline in the annual mean sea-surface temperature at a number of coastal recording stations in British Columbia, and this seems to have been a rebound from a less well-documented rise in sea-surface temperatures during the 20 years before that, which culminated in a peak around 1940. Salinity has likewise trended downwards during the last 30 years. The seabird colony size data before 1960 are so nonquantitative that it is impossible to be sure what changes in seabird populations and breeding sites may have taken place in response to these physical changes.