Her tenderly sympathetic nature sprang up at once to defend him against his own indictment.
“Oh, but you are not often disagreeable!” she said, in the frankest manner. “You can be perfectly charming if you like! When you first came to stay with us and help Dad I thought you a perfectly delightful man!--so brilliant and companionable!”

“Ah, those were in the early days!” he said, with a sigh. “The golden days of first acquaintance! You were very kind to me then,--though we had our little differences! But you didn’t mind helping me to light my pipe,--do you remember?--and once we had a pleasant walk across the fields. And you talked a great deal about love--”

“That was before the war!” she interposed.

“Before the war? Of course--certainly! Everything worth having was _before_ the war,--love, hope, confidence--_before_ the war--the world was better to live in _before_ the war. I grant you all that! We can, if we feel disposed to be poetical, look back and see a happy garden of Eden in England _before_ the war--but now the gates are closed and a sword turns every way forbidding re-entrance!”
“Naturally I do. And naturally I must. It does not actually surprise me, for war is a devastator of minds and morals. You thought me very harsh and unsympathetic at the time war was declared--and I know you considered me unpatriotic. Well, if it is unpatriotic to dislike the idea of men being slaughtered like animals in a meat-packer’s factory all for the pleasure of rival governments I _am_ unpatriotic, and glory in the fact! I have no sentiment on these matters. The waving of a flag does not excite me--I don’t think any man should fight for any other man. Let each one manage his own business.”
“You don’t like my point of view?” he queried, after a pause.
“I think you have a great deal of right and sense on your side,” she said, slowly. “But if nations did not fight for their existence where would they be?”
“They would settle down,” said the Philosopher, complacently. “Believe me they would settle down! It’s all a repetition of the Cain and Abel story--one brother is jealous of the other and commits murder. Why should such a precedent be maintained?”
“We were all happy enough and contented enough before the war,” pursued the Philosopher. “And we were immoral enough. If the war was intended to punish us for our immorality, it has failed in effect, for we are much more immoral now.”





