On March 28, 1834, the United States Senate voted to censure U.S. President Andrew Jackson over his actions to remove federal deposits from the Second Bank of the United States and his firing of Secretary of the Treasury William J. Duane in order to do so. Jackson was a Democrat, and the censure was passed by the Senate while under a Whig majority. In 1837, when the Senate had a Democratic majority, the then-lame duck president's party voted to "expunge" Jackson's censure.
This is the only time in which the U.S. Senate has censured a president. The censure of Andrew Jackson "remains the clearest case of presidential censure by resolution" in either chamber of the United States Congress, as no other president has had an explicit censure resolution adopted against them.
Background
Censures
A censure is a formal statement of disapproval issued by a group, such as a legislative body.
Presidential censure is not explicitly provided for in the Constitution of the United States, which does not even use the term "censure". Article One Section 5 Clause 2 does permit that, "each House may determine the Rules of its Proceedings, punish its Members for disorderly behavior, and, with the Concurrence of two thirds, expel a Member," which can be seen as permitting for censure by the chambers of the United States Congress of their own members. However, nothing in the United States Constitution explicitly outlines the ability for such action to be taken by a chamber of the United States Congress against individuals not belonging to that chamber. Despite the term "censure" not appearing in the United States Constitution, the chambers of the United States Congress adopted rules permitting for such punishment, which voices condemnation without having further consequence such as expulsion or removal from office.
Bank War
Political conflict arose over the opposition of President Andrew Jackson (a Democrat) to the existence of the Second Bank of the United States. In 1829, in his first annual message to the United States Congress, Jackson criticized the bank. Jackson believed that the bank was unconstitutional and worried about its centralization of financial influence. He believed it favored the elites over farmers and laborers. In 1832, he successfully vetoed a bill to recharter the bank. However, the bank still had a charter that would not expire until 1836. In 1833, Jackson had federal deposits withdrawn from the bank, causing great political controversy. In order to do this, on September 23, 1833, Jackson had dismissed Secretary of the Treasury William J. Duane, who had refused orders to do this, and in his place made the recess appointment of Roger Taney as secretary of the treasury.
Censure vote
In response to Jackson's actions, the Whig-controlled Senate expressed its disapproval by censuring him.
The Congress reconvened in December 1833, at which point Henry Clay introduced a two-part resolution which, in its first part, asserted that Jackson had
In its second part, this resolution asserted that Congress held a role in overseeing the nation's deposits and that the reason Taney had provided for removing federal deposits was "unsatisfactory and insufficient". Therefore, the reason given to censure was both the removal of the deposits and the dismissal of Duane.
The proposed censure was backed by Daniel Webster and John C. Calhoun. It was debated over a period of ten weeks. Clay, leading the effort to censure, described Jackson as a "backwoods Caesar" and his administration a "military dictatorship". Jackson would retaliate by calling Clay as "reckless and as full of fury as a drunken man in a brothel". The Senate ultimately adopted a revised censure resolution on March 28, 1834, and Jackson was thereby officially censured for violating the Constitution in a vote of 26–20. The full adopted resolution read,
While the charge could be considered an impeachable offense, only the House of Representatives could initiate an impeachment. Jackson alleged that the censure was unconstitutional because it amounted to the Senate acting beyond their authority by charging him with an impeachable offense.
The opposing parties accused the another of lacking credentials to represent the people. Jacksonian Democrats argued that the senators were beholden to the state legislatures that selected them; the Whigs pointed out that the president had been chosen by electors and not by direct election. On April 15, 1834, Jackson sent the Senate a lengthy message protesting his censure. In part, Jackson wrote,