Ontario Superior Court Justice Andrew Goodman must decide if the Court will grant an interlocutory [temporary] injunction to restrain the City of Hamilton from using its Parks Bylaw to remove homeless encampments on public lands. The Hamilton Community Legal Clinic (HCLC) is challenging the legality of the bylaw, arguing its blanket prohibition banning homeless individuals from encamping violates Section 7 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms which states, “Everyone has the right to life, liberty and security of the person and the right not to be deprived thereof except in accordance with the principles of fundamental justice.” The Superior Court is unlikely to hear the challenge until well into 2022. The question in front of Justice Goodman is what should happen in the interim – should the bylaw be frozen, enforcement restrained by a temporary framework, or should the City be able to enforce the bylaw at its sole discretion with no direction from the Court? If encampments are allowed in the interim, under what conditions would they exist? Goodman states he will issue his decision as soon as practically possible. Final written arguments from lawyers representing the City of Hamilton and the applicant homeless individuals were due today. The HCLC lawyers represent five homeless Hamiltonians who state they have no other option beyond sleeping in tents for various reasons. [Since the challenge filing on October 4, one of the five gained stable housing] Similar decisions in British Columbia and one other case in Ontario are informative to helping us understand what Justice Goodman will consider, and how the lawyers choose the points they argued during last week’s two days of oral arguments. (My Twitter threads of each day last week are here: Monday & Thursday) In determining if he will grant the injunction, Justice Goodman must apply the legal tests articulated by the Supreme Court of Canada in 1994’s RGR -MacDonald Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General) and Manitoba (A.G.) v. Metropolitan Stores Ltd. The test consists of three conjunctive parts. They are: 1) there is a serious question of law to be tried; 2) the applicant will suffer irreparable harm if the injunction is not granted; and 3) the balance of convenience favours the interlocutory injunction. If the injunction motion fails any of the tests, it will not be granted. In the October 2020 Toronto encampment case, Black et al. v. City of Toronto, 2020 ONSC 6398, Superior Court Justice Paul Schabas denied an application for an injunction preventing Toronto from removing encampments. Justice Schabas found the challenge met only two of the three tests. He agreed there is a serious question to be tried [the constitutionality of bylaws prohibiting the erecting tents to sleep in public places is a serious question of law that is not conclusively decided in Ontario]. He also agreed homeless individuals would suffer irreparable harm from being decamped. He wrote in his ruling [para 75], “I find that the irreparable harm branch of the RJR test has been met here, and discuss the City’s responses below in my discussion of the balance of inconvenience.” The City of Toronto successfully argued the encampments prevented some people from using public parks. The purpose of the park’s bylaw is to ensure public use of parks as a commons. The City showed it was actively engaged in providing indoor accommodation to those in encampments. Justice Schabas quoted extensively from Batty v. City of Toronto, a 2011 ruling regarding the “Occupy Toronto” camp in a park. “When read as a whole, the objective of the Parks By-law is quite clear and sensible – it is an attempt to balance, in a fair way, the different uses we wish to make of our public parks so, at the end of the day, we all get to enjoy them,” reads paragraph 95 of that decision. In paragraph 143 of his decision last October, Justice Schabas writes, “In my view, the public interest purpose of the By-law, to make parks available to everyone, outweighs the interests of the applicants who seek a sweeping order preventing enforcement of the By-law in all City parks. The City cannot have its hands tied and be prevented from managing its parks so that they are safe and accessible to everyone.” Advocates for the homeless regularly cite British Columbia court decisions that restrain municipal governments from removing encampments. These decisions are conditional upon circumstances in B.C., the key being a significant shortage of shelter beds. It is noteworthy that B.C. Supreme Court Chief Justice Christopher Hinkson in Abbotsford (City) v. Shantz, 2015 BCSC 1909, determined there is no Charter Right to housing.
Discovery
Will the Superior Court Grant an Interlocutory Injunction Preventing Removal of Encampments in Hamilton? – TPR Hamilton | Hamilton's Civic Affairs News Site
Tags