WASHINGTON - When U.S. President Donald Trump named a new national security adviser just over a week ago, current and former national security officials did more than just breathe a sigh of relief. Many expressed cautious optimism.
Those who knew or had worked previously with Army Lt. Gen. H.R. McMaster saw his selection as a sign the barely month-old Trump administration was starting to get its footing.
McMaster came in with a reputation for being able to quickly command respect, take a room full of divergent opinions and then forge them into solid policy recommendations, all the while not being afraid to stand up to his superiors.
“He is a convincing, well-thought out strategic thinker who’s able to persuade decision makers on how to do things the right way,” said Michael Pregent, a former intelligence officer who worked with McMaster in Iraq.
Now though, just over a week into the job, McMaster’s skills, and his ability to hold the president’s ear, will likely be put to the test as the White House begins to discuss the Pentagon’s long-awaited plan to destroy the Islamic State terror group.
Defense officials have described the plan, delivered to the White House Monday and later presented to key staffers by Defense Secretary Jim Mattis, as merely a preliminary document.
“This is really the framework for a broader discussion,” Pentagon spokesman Capt. Jeff Davis told reporters Monday. “There are a number of details that will need to be filled in as this plan moves forward.”
Pentagon officials also emphasized that the plan, even is these early stages, draws upon more than just military force.
“It is a plan to defeat IS rapidly … to do it on a global level with all instruments of national power in a synchronized way,” Davis said. “Diplomacy is a key part of the plan.”
How such a plan will fare with Trump, who has said he wants to “totally obliterate” IS, remains to be seen. And the plan’s reliance on diplomacy in addition to military might could signal a potential flashpoint, especially after the administration announced its intent to cut the State Department and foreign assistance budgets by at least 30 percent.
It might seem like a daunting task even for a national security adviser as widely respected as Lt. Gen. McMaster; but, those who know McMaster believe if anyone is able to navigate the internal political schisms, it’s the general.
“He’s the kind of guy who will sit there and listen to opposing points of view, get the best arguments from both sides and be able to collate, put it together and present it to the president,” Pregent said. "He won’t just let them sit at the table and say how much things aren’t working."
Pregent recounted one meeting in Iraq during which McMaster, then a colonel, was unrelenting in arguing a point with Gen. David Petraeus, who served as commander of multinational forces in Iraq.
“Gen. Petraeus said, ‘Alright. I got it. Enough,'” Pregent said. “But because of his [McMaster’s] adamant stance on a position, policies were changed.”
Still, a number of former national security officials question whether McMaster will be able to find a way to make sure that in the end, the president listens to him instead of other advisers like White House chief strategist Steve Bannon and senior policy adviser Stephen Miller, who have little formal foreign and national security policy experience.
“Domestic politics is always wrapped up in American foreign policy so I’d think it would be naive to think that you could exclude them entirely,” former NSC staffer Kenneth Pollack, now with the Brookings Institution, told VOA’s Press Conference USA. “But we just don’t know what role Steve Bannon will have.”
Pollack, who has known McMaster for decades, said his hope is that McMaster will find a way “to grab control over the National Security Council and the wider American national security process.”
“He’s obviously a tremendous battlefield commander,” Pollack added. “But he’s also demonstrated a real understanding that military force can only be part of a wider foreign panoply.”
Still, Bannon and Miller are not the only voices with which McMaster will have to compete. There’s also Sebastian Gorka, the deputy assistant to the president who sits on the White House’s Strategic Initiatives Group, a body described by some as a parallel NSC.
“The definition of victory for us is a very simple one,” Gorka said last week at the Conservative Political Action Conference, or CPAC, outside Washington. “We are going to make the black flag of jihad as repugnant around the world, not just here but around the world, as repugnant as the black, white and red swastika flag of the Third Reich.”