Hamilton City Council’s Planning Committee will debate a mid-rise development application in Ancaster’s Village Core (staff are recommending denial), allowing outdoor patio entertainment city-wide, permittingv temporary tents on patios for three more years, early stages of a new Master Plan for the Stelco lands, and an appeal of a staff decision ordering the removal of a top soil pile in rural Glanbrook. The meeting begins at 9:30 am on Tuesday morning and will be livestreamed on YouTube. City planning staff are recommending Council deny an application to build an eight-storey mixed-use development at 392 to 412 Wilson Street East saying it failed to conform with the Ancaster Wilson Street Secondary Plan and does not meet the intent of the Urban Hamilton Official Plan. In October, with the support of Ward 12 (Ancaster) Councillor Lloyd Ferguson, Council voted to approve moving the Philip Marr House, a designated heritage building from c. 1840, to facilitate this development. This planning application was filed on December 22, 2021. The City’s planning staff moved quickly to process the application to get it in front of Council for a denial vote prior to the 120 days threshold for a developer to file a non-decision appeal to the Ontario Land Tribunal. By denying the application before the April 20, 120-day deadline, Council requires the Ontario Land Tribunal to give consideration to both the position of Council and the feedback received from the public. Public notices were issued on February 4, 2022. 77 letters and emails opposing the development were received by City Hall. City planning staff state the development does not conform with Official Plan policies requiring developments to respect and enhance community character. “It is noted that the historic Ancaster downtown area is unique in that the street front has many breaks and spacing between buildings. Based on the scale and massing of the proposed building, the proposed development would interrupt this pattern. The solid massing is not representative of the village form of individual buildings along the street, the proposed height is more than triple what is currently supported, and the arrangement of building components does not complement the nature of the Ancaster Village Core area.” Other reasons for denial listed by staff include greater density than permitted, traffic impacts beyond what Wilson Street can absorb, and insignificant studies to determine if “the existing downstream sanitary system has sufficient capacity to support the proposed density on the site.” The Hamilton Conservation Authority is not satisfied with the proposed stormwater control measures. Among the 77 letters opposing this development application, a handful of letters express support for intensification along Wilson Street in the range of four to five storeys. “I feel that Ancaster residents will have to accept gentle densification in order to accommodate population growth within our urban boundary. This being said, the proposal for an 8 storey structure is too tall but I believe a 4 storey building would fit in nicely with the aesthetics of the town and would maximize the amount of housing it provides,” wrote Anka Cassar. “As an Ancaster resident, I am in favour of missing middle density (2-5 storeys) being allowed here. It is my belief that the Ancaster Secondary Plan is out of date and needs to be revised in light of the absolute necessity of municipalities to meaningfully address the climate emergency. Hamilton has declared a climate emergency and allowing well-planned infill projects to be built within all neighbourhoods across the city is one step we can take to do our part. Additionally, Hamilton City Council has voted for no urban expansion so gentle density in the city is now crucial if we are to avoid sprawl onto farm fields,” wrote Nancy Hurst. Hurst is a key organizer with Stop Sprawl HamOnt. The vast majority of the letters called for a maximum height of 2.5 to 3 storeys. There are over 200 pages of “housekeeping amendments” to the City’s various zoning bylaws and official plans. Councillors are being asked to approve a new Temporary Use By-law to allow businesses across Hamilton to continue operating outdoor patios using tents as they have during COVID. The extension will allow for the continued use of temporary tents by businesses and institutions such as places of worship, seniors’ homes, and educational establishments. The Temporary Use By-law allows tents to remain in place for up to six months, whereas Hamilton’s permanent bylaws limit their use to five consecutive days. It will remain in effect until March 31, 2025, to give time for the City’s planning staff to further review how businesses and institutions are using temporary tents.
Space Journal
Hamilton City Council Planning Committee for April 5, 2022 – TPR Hamilton | Hamilton's Civic Affairs News Site
Tags