?Africans are suspicious, because US officials are constantly stressing that the command will help to improve governance in Africa and to get involved in the aid sector. This makes Africans think the US is sugarcoating what is in fact a bitter pill and that there is something bad behind the creation of AFRICOM. Because why should a US military command become involved in aid
The views of Wafula Okumu, an analyst at South Africa?s Institute for Security Studies, reflect the deep mistrust on the continent over the United States? latest military initiative in Africa.
Concerns about US military involvement in the international aid sphere have increased ever since President Bush announced the formation of AFRICOM in February.
At a recent congressional hearing, Donald Payne, a member of the US House Committee on Foreign Affairs and the chairman of its subcommittee on Africa, said he found the AFRICOM proposal ?disconcerting.?
He expressed concern over what he termed the increased involvement of the US Department of Defense in foreign aid and assistance. Payne warned of the ?militarization? of US aid to Africa, with extremely detrimental consequences for the United States? image and standing on the continent.
Payne?s skepticism is mirrored by that in Africa itself.
Under AFRICOM, officials of key civilian US government agencies, such as the US Agency for International Development (USAID), will for the first time be integrated into a military command. Yet analysts such as Okumu point out that cooperation between the US military and civilian departments has in the past been ?very bad.?
Michael Hess, a retired US army colonel with more than 30 years of military experience, is considered in some quarters to be the embodiment of international fears that the American humanitarian aid sector is undergoing ?militarization.?
Hess came out of retirement in June 2005, when President Bush appointed him to a senior position at USAID. In justifying his presence as a career soldier, albeit retired, at what is the word?s leading civilian aid agency, Hess pointed out at a congressional hearing that USAID had for decades cooperated with the US military in providing humanitarian assistance to African countries wracked by disasters, conflicts and poverty and ?engaging in democratic reforms.?
He stressed that USAID missions in Djibouti, Ethiopia and Kenya had cooperated on educational projects with the US army. The military built the schools, Hess recalled, and USAID officials provided schoolbooks and teacher training.
Thus, maintains Hess, US civilian-military cooperation is ?nothing new,? and AFRICOM?s proposed objective of providing humanitarian assistance to Africa as one of its primary missions should not be regarded as a ?cover? for a more ?sinister? aim.
Hess emphasizes that AFRICOM will be ?more civilian in nature,? rather than the US aid sector becoming ?more military,? as some African leaders and analysts fear. Certain top leadership positions in AFRICOM, he says, have been reserved for civilian aid experts.
Theresa Whelan, the US deputy assistant secretary of defense for Africa and one of the planners of AFRICOM, has also tried to assuage concerns about its entrance into developmental affairs.
She dismisses fears that ?AFRICOM represents a militarization of US foreign policy in Africa? and that it will ?somehow become the lead US government interlocutor with Africa? as ?unfounded.?
?AFRICOM will support, not shape, US foreign policy on the continent,? Whelan insists. ?The secretary of state will remain the chief foreign policy advisor to the president, and the secretary of defense will remain his chief advisor on defense matters.?
She denies that AFRICOM will supersede USAID or the State Department in areas where those agencies have ?clear lines of authority as well as comparative advantages? to lead initiatives. Military commanders aren?t aid experts, she acknowledges.
But Stewart Patrick, an expert on weak states at the Center for Global Development in Washington, says AFRICOM?s aspiration to ?influence development? in Africa continues to raise ?hackles, particularly within the US foreign policy and development communities. Even within the State Department there is, under the surface, quite a bit of rumbling about the potential danger that AFRICOM will end up undermining the authority of the chiefs of mission ? that is, the US ambassadors in the field, who actually coordinate US policy there.?
Whelan says AFRICOM doesn?t intend to usurp the authority of American ambassadors in Africa.