"The most striking feature of the Committee is the preponderance of the alien element," wrote Stankevitch. "Jews, Georgians, Letts, Poles, and Lithuanians were represented out of all proportion to their numbers in Petrograd and in the country."

+----------+----------+-----------+-------+-----------+ | | | | | | Anarcho-Communists | Non-Party | Non-Party Conservatives ######## | ----#### | -------- -------- | (Peasants) | | Workmen (few) | | | Socialists Liberals | -------- +-----------+-------------+ | | | | +--------------+ | Non-Party | | | | ----#### | Constitutional- Radical- | Mostly Workmen | -------- -------- | | Democrats Democrats Social-Democrats Populists | | +--+---+----+ +---------------+-----------+ | | | | | | Bolsheviks | Edinstvo Social Popular Labour ######## | -------- Revolutionaries -------- -------- | | Socialists "Trudovik" Mensheviks | | +------+-------+ +---+-----------+ | | | | | Left Centre Right Internationalists Defencists #### ---### ---- ######## --------

The Russian Turmoil — Part 67

----#### Partly Defencist Partly Defeatist

The Russian Turmoil — Part 67

The following is a list of the first Presidium of the All-Russian Central Committee of the Soviets:--

The Russian Turmoil — Part 67

1 Georgian 5 Jews 1 Armenian 1 Pole 1 Russian (if his name was not an assumed one).

This exceptional preponderance of the alien element, foreign to the Russian national idea, could not fail to tinge the entire activities of the Soviet with a spirit harmful to the interests of the Russian State. The Provisional Government was the captive of the Soviet from the very first day, as it had under-estimated the importance and the power of that institution, and was unable to display either determination or strength in resisting the Soviet. The Government did not even hope for victory in that struggle, as, in its endeavour to save the country, it could not very well proclaim watchwords which would have suited the licentious mob and which emanated from the Soviet. The Government talked about duty, the Soviet about rights. The former "prohibited," the latter "permitted." The Government was linked with the old power by the inheritance of statesmanship and organisation, as well as the external methods of administration; whereas the Soviet, springing from mutiny and from the slums, was the direct negation of the entire old régime. It is a delusion to think, as a small portion of the moderate democracy still appear to do, that the Soviet played the part of "restraining the tidal wave of the people." _The Soviet did not actually destroy the Russian State, but was shattering it, and did so to the extent of smashing the Army and imposing Bolshevism on it._ Hence the duplicity and insincerity of its activities. Apart from its declarations, all the speeches, conversations, comments, and articles of the Soviet and of the Executive Committee, of its groups and individuals, came to the knowledge of the country and of the Front, and tended towards the destruction of the authority of the Government. Stankevitch wrote that not deliberately, but persistently, the Committee was dealing death-blows to the Government.