“But, even in spending on _himself_,” I persisted, “our typical rich man often does good, by employing people who would otherwise be out of work: and that is often better than pauperising them by _giving_ the money.”

“I’m glad you’ve said that!” said Arthur. “I would not like to quit the subject without exposing the _two_ fallacies of that statement—which have gone so long uncontradicted that Society now accepts it as an axiom!”

Sylvie and Bruno Concluded (Illustrated) — Part 27

“What are they?” I said. “I don’t even see _one_, myself.”

Sylvie and Bruno Concluded (Illustrated) — Part 27

“One is merely the fallacy of _ambiguity_—the assumption that ‘_doing good_’ (that is, benefiting somebody) is necessarily _a good thing to do_ (that is, a _right_ thing). The other is the assumption that, if one of two specified acts is _better_ than another, it is necessarily a _good_ act in itself. I should like to call this the fallacy of _comparison_—meaning that it assumes that what is _comparatively_ good is therefore _positively_ good.”

Sylvie and Bruno Concluded (Illustrated) — Part 27

“Then what is _your_ test of a good act?”

“That it shall be _our best_,” Arthur confidently replied. “And even _then_ ‘_we are unprofitable servants_.’ But let me illustrate the two fallacies. Nothing illustrates a fallacy so well as an extreme case, which fairly comes under it. Suppose I find two children drowning in a pond. I rush in, and save one of the children, and then walk away, leaving the other to drown. Clearly I have ‘_done good_,’ in saving a child’s life? But——. Again, supposing I meet an inoffensive stranger, and knock him down, and walk on. Clearly that is ‘_better_’ than if I had proceeded to jump upon him and break his ribs? But——”

“Those ‘buts’ are quite unanswerable,” I said. “But I should like an instance from _real_ life.”

“Well, let us take one of those abominations of modern Society, a Charity-Bazaar. It’s an interesting question to think out—how much of the money, that reaches the object in view, is _genuine_ charity; and whether even _that_ is spent in the _best_ way. But the subject needs regular classification, and analysis, to understand it properly.”

“I should be glad to _have_ it analysed,” I said: “it has often puzzled me.”

“Well, if I am really not boring you. Let us suppose our Charity-Bazaar to have been organised to aid the funds of some Hospital: and that A, B, C _give_ their services in making articles to sell, and in acting as salesmen, while X, Y, Z buy the articles, and the money so paid goes to the Hospital.