This species is less common in British Columbia than either Alaska or Washington. A possible reason for this is lack of suitable nesting areas. In Washington, the two largest colonies are at Protection Island in the Strait of Juan de Fuca and Destruction Island on the outer coast. Smaller numbers exist on other coastal islands and on Smith Island in the Strait of Juan de Fuca. The Smith Island colony is an interesting one since it appears that early human disturbance in the late 19th or early 20th century eliminated the species from the island. In their discussion of Smith Island, Jewett et al. (1953) made no mention of auklets, only of puffins and guillemots. Couch (1929) did not record the species in 1925. The colony now numbers about 600 pairs.
Although the horned puffin is one of the most abundant seabirds in other parts of Alaska, it is much less abundant in the southeastern portion. In addition to the information discussed by Sealy (1973), it now appears that this species may breed as far south as Triangle Island, British Columbia (K. Vermeer, personal communication; D. A. Manuwal, personal observation). Here, as on Forrester Island, it is greatly outnumbered by the tufted puffin. No data are available on the breeding or status of this species in the study area.
The tufted puffin is found breeding on scattered islands throughout the region. The largest known colonies are on Forrester Island, Alaska, Triangle Island, British Columbia, and Carroll Island, Washington. It is notably absent from most of the gulf and San Juan Islands. Even though puffins have apparently never been numerous in the San Juan Islands, their population has noticeably declined during the past 35 years. For example, Jewett et al. (1953) reported a colony of 50 pairs on Bare Island in 1937, but in 1973 only 2 pairs were counted (D. A. Manuwal, unpublished data). Likewise, in 1915 there were more than 250 pairs on Smith Island, but by 1916 there were only 75 pairs (Jewett et al. 1953). The decline is attributed to rapid erosion of the glacial-deposit cliffs. There are no puffins on Smith Island today, and the largest colony in the Puget Sound area is the 35 pairs on Protection Island (D. A. Manuwal, unpublished data).