Ritter, in his _History of Music_ (1876), disposes of Verdi in less than eleven short lines; but a little more justice, in the way of space, is done to the famous Italian by Naumann in his large, comprehensive _History of Music_, since he devotes to Verdi nearly two whole pages out of over thirteen hundred!
_Masters of Italian Music_ (R.A. Streatfeild), contains an appreciative biography of Verdi, based upon Pougin's work, together with some sound criticism upon Italian opera in general, and Verdi's in particular. A further work in the English language referring to Verdi is Elson's _Realm of Music_, chap. xviii. of which deals with the "Evolution of Verdi"; while in Ferris's _Lives of the Celebrated Composers_ there is an intelligent comparison between the _Otello_ of Verdi and Rossini. Dr. Parry's _Studies of the Great Composers_ omits Verdi altogether, the reason for which does not appear.
French works bearing upon Verdi are--Bertrand (Gustave), _Les nationalités musicales_, _étudiées dans le drame lyrique ..._, _ Verdisme et Wagnerisme_; Fouque (Octave), _Histoire du Théâtre Ventadour_ (1829-79),--_Opéra Comique_,--_Théâtre de la Renaissance_,--_Théâtre Italien, Verdi_; Maurel (Victor), _À propos de la mise-en-scène du drame lyrique "Otello,"_ being _Étude précédée d'aperçus sur le théâtre chanté en 1887_; Noufflard (Georges), _"Otello" de Verdi et le drame lyrique_.
The above enumerated writings, and the criticisms which have appeared more or less regularly in the _Athenæum_, _Times_, and _Illustrated London News_, constitute the chief of what has been published in the English and French languages relating to Verdi. We should not omit to state, however, that lately, especially since the production of _Falstaff_, not a little has been said, if not written, of the illustrious Verdi and his works. Sir A.C. Mackenzie's lectures on _Falstaff_ were particularly interesting. Therein the talented Principal of the Royal Academy of Music paid a high tribute to the personal qualities of the _doyen_ of composers. In tracing the gradual development of Verdi's genius Sir A.C. Mackenzie asserted that the composer did not show any Wagnerian influence in his later works--a judgment with which competent judges will agree. The articles which Dr. Villiers Stanford contributed to the _Daily Graphic_ concerning _Falstaff_, its wonderful humorous music, and the man who made it, were worthy of the journal and its talented special correspondent; while Mr. Joseph Bennett's tried and trusty pen has also been descried in more than one masterly article concerning Verdi in the _Daily Telegraph_ and _Musical Times_. In the _Musical Recollections_ of Mr. Wilhelm Kuhe, _entrepreneur_ and _raconteur_, are numerous critical passages and remarks concerning Verdi and several of his operas.