Another practically important item on which they differed was the immediate source of the devil's power to act upon visible man and matter. Calef claimed that "it is _only the Almighty_ that ... can commissionate him to hurt or destroy any;" while Mather said, "I am apt to think that the devils are seldom able to hurt us in any of our exterior concerns without a commission _from our fellow-worms_.... Permission from God for the devil to come down and break in upon mankind must oftentimes be accompanied with a commission from _some of mankind itself_."

Both of them conceded a commission by God to the devil. But we doubt whether his commission was ever more special than that which every created being, in either material or spiritual abodes, constitutionally holds at all times, to avail himself of whatever natural laws or forces his inherent powers and attending circumstances enable him to control. Words are often used which obscure proper, if not intended, meaning. Commission from God means no more than constitutional capabilities to perform at times certain specified things when conditions and circumstances favor command of natural forces. That special powers are often conferred upon mortals by some supernal beings whose recipients are prone to ascribe the gifts to _omnipotence_ is obviously true; though their increased abilities are only bestowments by finite invisibles.

Witchcraft of New England Explained by Modern Spiritualism — Part 16

_What_ witchcraft was, and _who_ commissioned the devil, whether God alone or God and man jointly, were the two most prominent questions about which those contestants differed. They agreed that the devil enacted both witchcraft and possession, but Calef's beliefs necessarily caused him to regard vast many cases as only simple possession, which Mather could, if he saw fit, regard as witchcrafts; and he sometimes seemingly did, when called to act publicly in connection with them. Mather at home and Mather abroad were not always in harmony.

Witchcraft of New England Explained by Modern Spiritualism — Part 16

Without designing, either here or subsequently, to make full presentation of the case of Margaret Rule, we shall freely adduce many parts of the record of it as helps in exhibiting leading positions and traits pertaining to the parties who crossed intellectual swords over them.

Witchcraft of New England Explained by Modern Spiritualism — Part 16