"Raleigh Was Right" is a poem by William Carlos Williams, published in 1940 and composed in response to the Elizabethan exchange between Christopher Marlowe, in "The Passionate Shepherd to His Love", and Walter Raleigh, with "The Nymph's Reply".

Horton Foote's Roots in a Parched Ground, the opening play of The Orphans' Home Cycle, takes its title from a line in this poem.

Raleigh Was Right

Text

Raleigh was right

We cannot go to the country

for the country will bring us

no peace

What can the small violets

tell us that grow on furry stems

in the long grass among

lance-shaped leaves?

Raleigh Was Right

Though you praise us

and call to mind the poets

who sung of our loveliness it was

long ago! long ago! when country people would plow and sow with flowering minds and pockets at ease—if ever this were true.

Raleigh Was Right

Not now. Love itself a flower

with roots in a parched ground. Empty pockets make empty heads. Cure it if you can but do not believe that we can live today in the country for the country will bring us no peace.

— William Carlos Williams

References

Christopher Marlowe

Cultural depictions of Walter Raleigh

Poetry by William Carlos Williams