"It's getting late, dad," murmured Helen, a bit confusedly glancing at her wrist watch. "You should have been at your office half an hour ago. And this is the first time I've known you to take an interest in a murder case."

"Once during the evening you gripped my hand and tried to point out something to me," pursued Mr. Hardwick, heedless of her remark. "You spoke incoherently, and I had not the faintest idea what it was about. Then, a minute or so before the tragedy, you left the box and hurried away. Still later, while the officer was questioning you, I felt you were concealing something."

The Gray Phantom — Part 21

Helen, her fingers tightening about a fork handle, shook her head. "I answered every question he put to me."

The Gray Phantom — Part 21

"I know, dear. Yet you withheld a secret of some kind from him."

The Gray Phantom — Part 21

"Not exactly. I--I merely refrained from telling him something that--that I might have told."

She hesitated for an instant. "If I had told all I had seen and heard, I wouldn't have been telling half of what I knew."

Mr. Hardwick leaned back against the chair and pondered this cryptic statement. He seemed puzzled rather than hurt by his daughter's evasive answers. Suddenly she looked up, saw the troubled expression in his face, and impulsively pushed back her chair and ran up behind him.

"Please don't ask me any more questions, dad." She put her arms around his neck and tilted her face to his. "It is true I held something back, but at the time I didn't know why. I merely felt that it wouldn't do to tell. This morning, after lying awake most of the night, I knew I had done the right thing." She gave a little laugh. "Isn't it just like a woman to act first and look into her reasons afterward?"

"I--well, I suppose so. And what were your reasons?"

"Would you be hurt if I told you I would rather not explain them just now?"

"No; I trust you. Experience has taught me that I can depend upon you in spite of your mysterious little ways and madcap pranks. There is one thing I wish you would tell me, though." He stopped, fumbling for words. "Was your reticence last night prompted by a wish to shield someone?"

"No," was her prompt reply, and her eyes gazed frankly into his. "What put such a thought into your head?"

"I scarcely know. You'll think I am an old fool, but it occurred to me that perhaps you had discovered something that led you to think that Mr. Shei and The Gray Phantom are identical."