,
The future foreign policy of the United States will
be largely determined by the peace soon to be concluded
with Spain. Although a preliminary protocol has been
signed, I shall discuss the matter as if it were an open
one, which it really will be so long as the Senate has not
ratified the treaty.
If our Government insists upon Spain altogether with
drawing her power from this hemisphere, or even from
all of her colonies, there will hardly be much dissent
among us. The serious differences of opinion begin with
the question whether those colonies or any of them shall
be annexed to the United States, or whether they shall be
made independent, to govern themselves, or whether
other arrangements shall be made to provide for their
future.
The question whether any of them shall be annexed
to the United States presents itself under three different
aspects: (1) as a question of morals, of honor; (2) as a
question of institutional policy; and (3) as a question of
commercial interests.
As to the question of morals, of honor, we have to
remember that President McKinley in his annual message
in December last, in discussing various methods of
solving the Cuban difficulty, made the following emphatic
declaration: “I speak not of forcible annexation, for that
cannot be thought of. That by our code of morals would
be criminal aggression.” It will not be denied that
although speaking of Cuban affairs, the President thus
stated a principle of general application. It would be
absurd to say that to annex Cuba by means of force would
be “criminal aggression,” but that it would be something
quite justifiable to annex Porto Rico or the Philippine
Islands by the same means.
We have also to remember that the war with Spain was
virtually initiated by a resolution adopted by Congress, April 19th, which declared that the people of Cuba should be free and independent, that, moved by a sense of duty, the United States demanded the withdrawal of the Spanish forces from Cuba, that the President should use the Army and Navy and Militia “to the extent as may be necessary to carry these resolutions into effect”—that is, to liberate Cuba and that such liberation and the pacification of Cuba accomplished, the United States, emphatically disclaiming any disposition or intention to
annex Cuba, would leave the government of that island
to the people thereof.
This resolution was adopted to justify our war with
Spain before the public opinion of mankind. All the
world was to understand that only a sense of duty put
arms in our hands; that we were impelled by a high
purpose of noble disinterestedness; that this was to be
a war of liberation and humanity, not of conquest or
self-aggrandizement. This we solemnly proclaimed. In
proclaiming it we asked the world to believe what we said. It is quite evident that if this proclamation had been open to the construction that, while we would not annex Cuba, we would annex whatever else might come conveniently our way, it would have met with general derision and contempt. Our own people would have indignantly protested against the mockery; and when some foreign papers charged us with hypocrisy, and predicted that this war of liberation and humanity would turn out to be a land-grabbing scheme, we grew very angry and loudly repelled the vile imputation.
It may be somewhat old-fashioned, but I still believe
that a nation, no less than an individual man, is in honor
bound to keep its word; that it can neither preserve its
self-respect nor safe standards of morality among its
own people, nor the esteem and confidence of mankind, unless it does, and that the maintenance of perfect good faith will finally turn out to be the best investment—that honesty is and will remain the best policy. And now I ask the advocates of annexation among us, whether if this Republic under any pretext annexes any of the Spanish colonies, it does not really turn this solemnly advertised war of liberation and humanity into a war of self-aggrandizement! I ask them what they will have to say when our detractors repeat against us their charges of hypocrisy and selfish motives! I ask them who will