THESE two cases were appeals from the circuit court of the United States for the eastern district of Virginia. Being exactly alike, it will only be necessary to state the first.
A motion was made to dismiss the first case upon the following grounds, and was argued by Mr. Robinson, and Mr. Pallon in support thereof, and opposed by Mr. Johnson and Mr. Lyons.
The counsel for the motion filed the following certificate:--
I, Philip Mayo, clerk of the United States court for the fourth circuit and eastern district of Virginia, do certify that, in a suit in chancery in the said court between Wyndham Kemp, assignee in bankruptcy of John L. Hudgins, a bankrupt plaintiff, and Elliott W. Hudgins and John L. Hudgins, defendants, a final decree was rendered on the twenty-seventh day of June 1855; that the term of the court at which the same was rendered, ended on the twenty-eighth day of that month; that afterwards in the vacation of the said court, to wit, on the 16th of October, 1855, there was filed in my office, a writing under the hand of R. B. Taney, judge of the said court, bearing date on the thirteenth of that month, whereby it was 'ordered that the appeal in this case, which was taken in open court when the decree was pronounced, be entered accordingly on the order book of the court of the last term, to wit: of May term, 1855;' that in view of this order, the clerk on its being so filed wrote on the order book of the court, at the foot of the decree of the 27th of June, 1855, the following words: 'And from the foregoing decree the defendants prayed an appeal, which was granted them on giving bond and security to be approved by the court in double the amount of said decree, conditioned for their prosecuting the said appeal;' and that at the time of filing the said vacation order of the judge, there was also filed in the clerk's office, bond and security approved by the said judge in double the amount of said decree, conditioned for their prosecuting the said appeal. Given under my hand this 21st day of April, 1856.
P. MAYO, Clerk.
And then made the following points for dismissal:--
I. It cannot take jurisdiction of the appeals as having been allowed by the court, when the record as it stood at the end of the term, and as it was then signed by the presiding judge, shows no allowance of such appeals. In Burch, & c. v. White, 3 Rand. 104, cited in 1 Rob. Pract. 642, (old edit.,) it appeared that at the preceding term the appeal was prayed and bond and security then given; but the clerk of the court had omitted to enter on the records thereof the appeal so granted. The supreme court of appeals of Virginia decided that this omission could not be remedied by an amendment of the record made after the term had ended; and the appeal was therefore dismissed. Though the appeal bond was filed with the clerk, it was considered there was nothing in the record to amend by. A fortiori, it must be so in these cases, when no appeal bond was given during the term; and there was nothing whatever to amend by.
II. If the appeal had been duly allowed, the appeal bond has not been properly given.