The question for decision is whether a willfully false statement of a material fact, made by an attorney under oath during the District Court's examination, under its local rule, into his fitness to practice before it, constitutes perjury within the meaning of 18 U.S.C. § 1621, 18 U.S.C.A. § 1621.

Acting under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1654, 2071, 28 U.S.C.A. §§ 1654, 2071, and Rule 83 of Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, 28 U.S.C.A. authorizing federal courts to prescribe rules for the conduct of their business, the District Courts for the Northern and Southern Districts of Iowa promulgated local rules governing practice in those courts. Their Rule 3, in pertinent part, provides:

United States v. Hvass/Opinion of the Court

'All attorneys residing outside of the State of Iowa and having civil matters in the court shall associate with them a resident attorney on whom notice may be served and who shall have the authority to act for and on behalf of the client in all matters * * *. Non-resident attorneys who have so associated with them a resident attorney shall be permitted to participate in a particular case upon satisfactory showing of good moral character.

United States v. Hvass/Opinion of the Court

'Provided further that where the action is one to recover damages for personal injuries sustained in Iowa by one who at the time was a resident of Iowa * * *, the Court may on its own motion, or on motion of a member of the bar of either District, before permitting a non-resident attorney to participate in the case, require a satisfactory showing that the connection of the said attorney (with the case) was not occasioned or brought about in violation of the standards of conduct specified in Rule 8 hereof. The court as a part of said showing may require the plaintiff and the said attorney to appear and be examined under oath.'

United States v. Hvass/Opinion of the Court

Appellee, an attorney residing and maintaining his office in Minneapolis, Minnesota, had instituted two actions in the District Court for the Northern District of Iowa, as counsel for citizens of Iowa, seeking damages for bodily injuries which they had sustained in that State. On October 3, 1955, the court, acting under its Rule 3, entered an order scheduling a hearing to be held by the court on October 12, 1955, for the purpose of affording an opportunity to appellee to show that his connection with the two damage suits was not brought about in violation of the standards of conduct specified in its Rule 8, and directing appellee to appear at that time and to submit to an examination under oath, if he wished further to participate as counsel in those actions. Appellee appeared at the hearing and, after being sworn by the Clerk, was examined by the District Attorney on matters deemed relevant to the hearing. On November 1, 1955, the court entered an order finding that 'the applicant (had) not made satisfactory showing of the matters which must be satisfactorily shown under said Local Rule 3,' and it struck his appearance as counsel in the two damage actions from the record.

On March 20, 1956, a four-count indictment was returned against appellee in the same District Court. Each count charged that appellee, while under oath as a witness at the hearing of October 12, 1955, 'unlawfully, wilfully, and knowingly, and contrary to (his) oath, (stated) material matters which he did not believe to be true' (in particulars set forth in each count), 'in violation of Section 1621, Title 18 United States Code.' Appellee moved to dismiss the indictment for failure of any of the counts to state an offense against the United States. The court, after full hearing upon the motion, concluded 'that Rule 3, under which the defendant took his oath, is not such a law of the United States as was intended by Congress to support an indictment for perjury,' and, on that ground, dismissed the indictment. 147 F.Supp. 594, 597. The Government brought the case here by direct appeal under the Criminal Appeals Act, 18 U.S.C. § 3731, 18 U.S.C.A. § 3731. We postponed further consideration of the question of jurisdiction to the hearing on the merits, 353 U.S. 980, 77 S.Ct. 1282, 1 L.Ed.2d 1140.