Rennie was succeeded by Mr. James Davidson, a local reporter, who soon resigned the office into the hands of Mr. Thomas Hay Marshall, also a reporter, who came to be known as the "historian of Perth." Before the end of the year, however, this periodical may be said to have entered upon another stage of its existence, with an alteration of the title to "The Perth and Dundee Saturday Journal," and in an eight-page issue.
The first number was dated 27th November, 1841, and in No. 28, July 16th, 1842, Mr. Fittis began a serial story entitled "The Mysterious Monk." This issue ran on to fifty-two numbers, the last one appearing 31st December, 1842. In this number it was announced that "the second volume of the 'JOURNAL' will appear on the day it is due--on the first Saturday of 1843, and will continue to be issued, as usual, weekly." It was not, however until Saturday, January 21st, 1843, that the first number of Vol. II. made its appearance. The volume consisted of fifty numbers of eight pages, as before, but the last, which was issued on Saturday, 30th December, 1843, consisted of two leaves (4 pp.) only, and intimated that the Journal was to be continued in 1844, and that the talented writer (Fittis) of "Anguswood" and many other tales which have appeared in the Journal, and met with so favourable reception, is, in an early number, to favour us with the first chapter of another tale entitled the "Mosstrooper." Accordingly, in 1844, the Journal again made its appearance, this time under the title of "The Perth and Dundee Journal," and in this year's issue, as promised, the tale called "The Mosstrooper," by Fittis, was first published. With this year the career of the Journal was terminated.
The literary ability of Mr. Fittis had been so conspicuously displayed in connection with the "Journal," that when Mr. Fisher contemplated a new venture it was to Fittis he first looked for aid. On 1st January, 1845, there was started a periodical entitled "The Tales of Scotland," similar in character to Wilson's "Tales of the Borders," but taking a wider scope. Fittis was editor and principal contributor, and he was assisted by Thomas Soutar, Solicitor, Crieff, George Hay of Rait, and James Stewart of Dunkeld. The experiment was entirely successful. So great was the demand for the "Tales" that the first twelve numbers were reprinted three times, and Fisher spared no effort to push the sale of the publication in London, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Dundee, and Aberdeen. The work was completed in four half-yearly volumes, the greater portion of the contents having been written by Mr. Fittis. Shortly after its completion Mr. Fittis became a contributor to "The Scottish Miscellany," which was begun in 1847. Four years afterwards (1851) he edited a short series under the title of "Miscellany of Scottish Tradition," and in the following year (1852) he began the "Tales and Traditions of Scotland," in which he re-published "The Mosstrooper" in a revised and improved version. The tales in this periodical were all from his industrious pen.