What shall we say of a man who quotes one of the best things in the _Scènes de la Vie de Bohême_ and then blandly remarks that he does not see anything funny in it?

That is precisely what Mr. Rhodes does. He prints the program of the soirée given by Rodolphe and Marcel, and then observes, with the solemnity of a Central Park pelican: “There is nothing very humorous in this, as will be observed, and yet it may be regarded as one of the best specimens of Murger’s _genre_.”

The Literary Shop, and Other Tales — Part 18

Well, I can inform Mr. Rhodes, and also the simple-minded folk who believed in him because he wrote for the magazines, that if that chapter of the _Vie de Bohême_ is not funny, there is nothing funny in the world. It begins with the “opening of the salons and entry and promenade of the witty authors of the _Mountain in Labor_, a comedy rejected by the Odéon Théâtre,” and closes with the significant warning that “persons attempting to read or recite poetry will be cast into outer darkness.”

The Literary Shop, and Other Tales — Part 18

The gifted Mr. Rhodes was probably in doubt as to the humor of this passage because it is not prefixed with “Our friend K---- sends the ‘Drawer’ the following good one,” and because its point is not indicated by italics after the fashion of humor of the _Ayer’s Almanac_ school; but he can rest assured that that brief quotation from Murger is the funniest thing in his essay, always excepting his own bovine lack of perception. It is particularly funny to me because I have sometimes witnessed the “entry and promenade” through the salons of the witty authors of stories that have been accepted by magazines--a spectacle calculated to produce prolonged and hilarious merriment--and I have often wished that the recitation clause in the Bohemian’s program could be enforced in every house in the town.

The Literary Shop, and Other Tales — Part 18

I have devoted a good deal of space to this long-forgotten article because it is a fair sample of the sort of stuff that is offered to us from time to time, prepared especially for us, like so much baby’s food, by men and women who are carefully selected by the magazine barons, and who generally rival Mr. Rhodes in point of simian incompetence and utter lack of all appreciative or perceptive qualities.

But let us turn from the awful spectacle of Mr. Rhodes standing like a lone penguin in the very midst of the Latin Quarter of Paris, and wailing mournfully about the poor girl who “sometimes compels the young man to marry her.” A far brighter picture is that presented by the distinguished English gentleman who, having won the highest distinction with his pencil, takes up his pen with the air of one who is enjoying a holiday fairly earned by a lifetime of toil, and portrays the real Quartier Latin of the Second Empire with a humor that makes us think of Henri Murger, and with a delicacy of touch, a human sympathy, and a tendency to turn aside and moralize that place him very near to Thackeray.