It amuses me to give, at a great distance of time, a small Rowland for a small Oliver,[53] which I received, _de par l'Eglise_,[54] so far as lay in the Oliver-carrier more than twenty years ago. The following contribution of mine to _Notes and Queries_ (3d Ser. vi. p. 175, Aug. 27, 1864) will explain what I say. There had been a complaint that a contributor had used the term _Papist_, which a very excellent dignitary of the Papal system pronounced an offensive term:
The term _papist_ should be stripped of all except its etymological meaning, and applied to those who give the higher and final authority to the declaration _ex cathedrâ_[55] of the Pope. See Dr. Wiseman's[56] article, _Catholic Church_, in the _Penny Cyclopædia_.
What is one to do about these names? First, it is clear that offence should, when possible, be avoided: secondly, no one must be required to give a name which favors _any_ assumption made by those to whom it is given, and not { 27} granted by those who give it. Thus the subdivision which calls itself distinctly _Evangelical_ has no right to expect others to concede the title. Now the word _Catholic_, of course, falls under this rule; and even _Roman Catholic_ may be refused to those who would restrict the word _Catholic_ to themselves. _Roman Christian_ is unobjectionable, since the Roman Church does not deny the name of Christian to those whom she calls heretics. No one is bound in this matter by Acts of Parliament. In many cases, no doubt, names which have offensive association are used merely by habit, sometimes by hereditary transmission. Boswell records of Johnson that he always used the words "dissenting teacher," refusing _minister_ and _clergyman_ to all but the recipients of episcopal ordination.
This distinctive phrase has been widely adopted: it occurs in the Index of 3d S. iv. [_Notes and Queries_]. Here we find "Platts (Rev. John), Unitarian teacher, 412;" the article indexed has "Unitarian minister."
This, of course is habit: an intentional refusal of the word _minister_ would never occur in an index. I remember that, when I first read about Sam Johnson's little bit of exclusiveness, I said to myself: "Teacher? Teacher? surely I remember One who is often called _teacher_, but never _minister_ or _clergyman_: have not the dissenters got the best of it?"