Finally, it is a matter of observation that modification of the physical conditions under which a species lives favours the development of varieties and races.

Hence, in the case of two specimens having respectively the characters A and A + _n_, although, _primâ facie_, they are of distinct species; yet if a large collection shows us that the interval between A and A + _n_ is filled up by forms of A having traces of _n_, and forms of A + _n_ in which _n_ becomes less and less, then it will be { 293} concluded that A and A + _n_ are races of one species and not separate species. And this conclusion will be fortified if A and A + _n_ occupy different stations in the same geographical area.

The Crayfish — Part 150

Even when no transitional forms between A and A + _n_ are discoverable, if _n_ is a small and unimportant difference, such as of average size, colour, or ornamentation, it may be fairly held that A and A + _n_ are mere varieties; inasmuch as experience proves that such variations may take place comparatively suddenly; or the intermediate forms may have died out and thus the evidence of variation may have been effaced.

The Crayfish — Part 150

From what has been said it follows that the groups termed morphological species are provisional arrangements, expressive simply of the present state of our knowledge.

The Crayfish — Part 150

We call two groups species, if we know of no transitional forms between them, and if there is no reason to believe that the differences which they present are such as may arise in the ordinary course of variation. But it is impossible to say whether the progress of inquiry into the characters of any group of individuals may prove that what have hitherto been taken for mere varieties are distinct morphological species; or whether, on the contrary, it may prove that what have hitherto been regarded as distinct morphological species are mere varieties.

What has happened in the case of the crayfish is this: { 294} the older observers lumped all the Western European forms which came under their notice under one species, _Astacus fluviatilis_; noting, more or less distinctly, the stone crayfish and the noble crayfish as races or varieties of that species. Later zoologists, comparing crayfishes together more critically, and finding that the stone crayfish is ordinarily markedly different from the noble crayfish, concluded that there were no transitional forms, and made the former into a distinct species, tacitly assuming that the differential characters are not such as could be produced by variation.