Table 6. _Life history data for certain northern seabirds._[44]

Annual adult Age at first survival breeding Clutch Species (%) (years) size

Conservation of marine birds of northern North America: — Part 203

Fulmar 94 7+ 1 Gannet _(Morus bassanus)_ 94 (4)-5+ 1 Manx shearwater 93-96 (4)-5+ 1 Shag 85 (♂) (2)-3 3-4 80 (♀) Herring gull 91-96 3.5 (♂) (2)-3 5 (♀) Black-legged kittiwake 88 4-5 (♂) 3 3-4 (♀) Arctic tern 89-91 (2)-3+ 2 75 82[45] Common murre 87 3+? 1 Black guillemot 88+[46] 3?[46] 2[46] Cassin's auklet 83[47] 3[47] 1

Conservation of marine birds of northern North America: — Part 203

There is some evidence of density-dependent population size control in seabirds, although much of it is circumstantial. For example, there are large nonbreeding populations in such diverse species as shags, herring gulls, and Cassin's auklets, which move into a breeding area when established adults are removed or colonize new breeding areas (J. C. Coulson, personal communication; Kadlec and Drury 1968; Drury and Nisbet 1972; Manuwal 1974_b_). Lack (1966) and Ashmole (1971) presented other arguments for density-dependence. Density-dependent mortality is difficult to demonstrate, at best, and may be obscured by interpopulation movements (Drury and Nisbet 1972).

Conservation of marine birds of northern North America: — Part 203

If long life is a life history option, a low annual reproductive effort could be favored in several ways. First, it may be necessary for insuring long life, if breeding has a serious negative feedback on life expectancy (Calow 1973). Second, if survival of offspring is more unpredictable than that of adults, low annual effort may be selected so that reproductive effort will not be wasted in years when young have poor chances of survival. Unpredictable and variable first-year survival in seabirds has been documented (Potts 1968; Drury and Nisbet 1972). In addition, some seabirds show adaptations that allow high reproductive success in any given year but which do not drain off resources if the season turns out to be poor (e.g., small last eggs in the clutch or asynchronous hatching, both of which lead to elimination of the smallest chicks when conditions are poor [Parsons 1970; E. H. Dunn 1973]).

It should be emphasized that the factors involved in the evolution of life histories are complex and poorly understood, and simple formulas should not be expected to apply to all situations (Wilbur et al. 1974).