address recently delivered before the Naval War

College at Newport by our new Assistant Secretary of the

Navy, Mr. , has deservedly attracted

much attention. It was a very eloquent and forcible

defence of the proposition that this republic must have

a great navy in order to be prepared for war, and that in

being well prepared for war is the surest means of

preserving peace. The building of a big navy was thus

presented to us as essentially a peace measure.

Had this plea for the preservation of peace by the

construction of a large number of war-ships come from a

member of the Peace Society or from any one else known

as an earnest advocate of the peaceable settlement of

international disputes, it would stand on firmer ground

than it does coming from Mr. . This is said

in the kindest spirit and without the slightest desire to

disparage his character or the eminent services he has in

various ways rendered to the public. The fact is that

Mr. has always with perfect frankness confessed himself to be what is currently called a Jingo. But he stands foremost among the sincere and honest men of that class. He is not one of those who would urge his country into a war, and then try to get a contract or some cheap popularity by talking or writing bloody patriotism while others had to do the fighting. He would be prompt to seek the post of danger for himself. The story is told of him that some years ago, when there seemed to be a prospect of a conflict with Chile, Mr. wrote to the War Department asking for himself the privilege of being the first volunteer for active service. And it is probably doing him no injustice to say that when the Chilean trouble was amicably composed, he may have been a little disappointed by being thus deprived of the chance of fighting for his country. Aside from his patriotic impulses, Mr. is essentially a fighting man by temperament. Nobody relishes the “joy of the conflict” with greater zest than he does; and it is therefore

Harper's Weekly Editorials by Carl Schurz/Armed or Unarmed Peace

not surprising that a peace argument should have been an

awkward and somewhat bewildering task to him.

Harper's Weekly Editorials by Carl Schurz/Armed or Unarmed Peace

Every attentive reader of Mr. oration will

be struck by the bellicose flavor pervading it. It is

really a panegyric on war. With almost poetic enthusiasm

he describes how war arouses noble emotions, stimulates

patriotism, brings forth heroic examples and how “no triumph

of peace is quite so great as the supreme triumphs

of war.” To be sure, he has also a word of recognition for

the merits of peace, but it is rather of the conventional

and perfunctory kind. Peace must be quite honorable to

be entitled to respect, and Mr. seems to think

that we must look sharp or peace will be as likely as not to

become dishonorable and craven without our knowing it. On the whole he is inclined to believe that a long peace will have a tendency to make a people effeminate and unpatriotic, and that it will require an occasional spell of blood-letting and devastation to restore or keep up the necessary vigor, manliness, elevation of sentiment and patriotic devotion. Mr. in his combative ardor has probably not noticed the logical quandary into which he has reasoned himself. It is this: according to him a long peace has a tendency to make a people effeminate and unpatriotic, while war will invigorate a people and inspire patriotism. But he argues also that the building of a great fleet of war-ships will be a means not to bring on war, but to preserve peace. Ergo, the building of a great war fleet will effect that which promotes effeminacy and languishing patriotism. Mr. , according to his own theory, will hardly accept this result as satisfactory to himself. His argument in favor of a big war fleet as an instrumentality of peace comes thus to an untimely end.

Harper's Weekly Editorials by Carl Schurz/Armed or Unarmed Peace

In truth those among us who are really in favor of

peaceable methods of adjusting international differences

are not in favor of building a great war fleet, while almost

all the zealous advocates of a great war fleet belong to the

Jingo class, many of whom are not nearly as honest and

unselfish as Mr. is, and would hesitate little to drive their country into a war with some foreign power without necessity.