The respondent makes and sells safety razors and blades. The petitioner makes and sells only blades. The Gaisman patent, No. 1,633,739, owned by the respondent, covers both safety razor blades and razors, and for the alleged infringement by petitioner of claims 1 and 2 covering blades this suit was brought. The claims are so nearly alike that quotation of claim 1 will suffice: 'A blade having a non-circular opening substantially centrally disposed to retain the blade in shaving relation to a guard member, said blade having means spaced from said opening to cooperate with a clamping member to retain the latter in shaving relation to the blade independent of the guard member.'

The novelty claimed for the patented article is that the blade acts as a positioning device or key to maintain in cap, the blade itself, and the guard, in proper relation to each other for shaving.

Essex Razor Blade Corporation v. Gillette Safety Razor Company/Opinion of the Court

The District Court dismissed the bill on the ground that the patent was void for want of invention. The Circuit Court of Appeals reversed, holding that the patent disclosed invention and was infringed by the petitioner's blade. The Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has decided that a blade like the petitioner's in all important features does not infringe. In view of the conflict certiorari was granted. 298 U.S. 649, 56 S.Ct. 834, 80 L.Ed. 1378.

Essex Razor Blade Corporation v. Gillette Safety Razor Company/Opinion of the Court

Safety razors of the Gillette type combine these elements: A guard, a cap or backing member, a blade, a handle, and means to clamp the blade in shaving position between the cap and the guard. King C. Gillette accomplished a major advance in the art when he conceived a double-edged blade so thin and flexible as to require external support to give rigidity to its cutting edge and a safety razor embodying such a blade. In 1904 he was awarded a patent, No. 755,134, for this invention. He claimed 'as a new article of manufacture a detachable razor-blade of such thinness and flexibility as to require external support and give rigidity to its cutting edge.' He made further claims of which the following may be taken as typical: 'In a razor, the combination with a perforated blade of a holder comprising a guard, a backing, a handle, and positioning and clamping means passing through the perforations in the blade.'

Essex Razor Blade Corporation v. Gillette Safety Razor Company/Opinion of the Court