?SADC, they have bought into Mugabe?s characterization of the crisis, where he pretentiously projects himself as a victim of Western countries. A number of the leadership in the SADC region have been compromised by the way they?ve accepted that message,? says Briggs Bomba, a former student leader in Zimbabwe who now works for the Africa Action lobby group in Washington, D.C.
Bomba says many Zimbabweans are ?bitter? as a result of SADC?s inability to secure substantive reforms in the southern African nation, which is plagued by food and fuel shortages, mass unemployment and frequent price increases.
?Africa has dealt with Mugabe with kid gloves,? says Bomba.
President Mugabe has presided over the worst economic crisis in Zimbabwe?s history, but he remains a hero to millions in the developing world. In the 1970s, he led a war of liberation against the white minority Rhodesian government and won independence for his people. He continues to be much admired around Africa for his frequent anti-Western diatribes, and for his policy of confiscating commercial farms from white people for redistribution to black Zimbabweans.
?SADC and others in Africa feel they can?t be seen to be criticizing a man like Mugabe, a revolutionary. He is like the untouchable chief of an old boy?s club,? says Sydney Masamvu, a Zimbabwean analyst at the International Crisis Group.
SADC, says Bomba, has never ?unequivocally condemned? the human rights atrocities suffered by Zimbabweans in recent years, allegedly at the hands of the ruling ZANU-PF party and its machinery.
?The Mbeki-led process didn?t help the people of Zimbabwe at all. Yet SADC wasted no time in congratulating itself for so-called success?. One would have expected that SADC would come out with a statement at least condemning the party (ZANU-PF) that was responsible for undermining that dialogue, but that did not happen,? Bomba says.
President Mbeki has consistently refused to abandon his policy of ?quiet diplomacy? with regard to the Zimbabwe crisis.
?Despite all that?s been said about what South Africa should do, Mbeki has never exercised much leverage over Mugabe,? states Masamvu.
?Most Zimbabwean civic groups denounced the Mbeki-mediated process from the outset, because they were not inclusive; they left out some parties and only included the M.D.C. (Movement for Democratic Change) and the ruling party,? explains Blessing Zulu, a journalist with VOA?s Zimbabwe service.
?People also said that in agreeing to the talks, President Mugabe was merely buying time because he agreed to the mediation directly after (M.D.C. leader Morgan) Tsvangirai and other civic leaders had been badly assaulted (in March last year by the police during demonstrations against Mugabe). People said Mr. Mugabe was just trying to divert attention from his security forces? brutality ? which, looking back, he seems to have achieved.?
Zulu says many Zimbabweans are of the opinion that Mr. Mbeki should have ?dropped this policy of quiet diplomacy and used a megaphone, because gently prodding Mugabe in the direction of democracy has not worked.?
South Africa?s ruling African National Congress party, which also waged a vicious liberation struggle against white minority rule, has strong ties with President Mugabe.
?They are therefore hesitant to chastise him for anything he does,? says Masamvu. ?He is their friend ? no matter what he does.?
Bomba adds that Zimbabwean citizens themselves have a ?bit of a love-hate relationship? with South Africa: Many condemn the country?s government for not taking a strong stand against Mr. Mugabe, while at the same time thousands continue to illegally cross the crocodile-infested Limpopo River in search of a better life.
Yet, says Zulu, even Zimbabwean refugees living in South Africa are certain: ?If President Mbeki [had publicly condemned] the human rights abuses in Zimbabwe, President Mugabe would have changed course.?
Michelle Gavin, of the United States? Council on Foreign Relations and author of the council?s Special Report on Zimbabwe, says, ?Everyone (in the U.S.) wishes that the SADC process could have been more successful. There?s a sense that key South African figures are perhaps a bit distracted by political developments within South Africa itself.?
President Bush has himself expressed disappointment with Pretoria?s indecisiveness with regard to its northern neighbor.
?I was hoping that the South African government would have been more pro-active in its intercession, to help the people of Zimbabwe. You know, (such intercession is) not anti-anybody; it?s pro-people,? Mr. Bush commented recently.