Luna Perez v. Sturgis Public Schools, 598 U.S. 142 (2023), was a United States Supreme Court decision in which the Court held that an Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) lawsuit seeking compensatory damages for denial of a Free and Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) can proceed without exhausting the administrative procedures of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), because compensatory damages are not available under IDEA. This case holds significant implications for disabled students who allege they were failed by school officials.

Background

Miguel Luna Perez, a deaf student, attended schools in Michigan's Sturgis Public Schools District from age 9 to 20. Under his individualized education program (IEP), Sturgis schools were to provide aides to translate classroom instruction into sign language. However, Perez's parents alleged that Sturgis failed to provide qualified aides. In fact, Sturgis never provided Perez with a qualified sign-language interpreter. One aide assigned to Perez, Gayle Cunningham, did not know sign language but did attempt to teach herself. Cunningham never had any official training or certification in sign language. This was to be his sole facilitator of communication. It was also alleged Sturgis failed to properly evaluate her interpreting ability and misrepresented her skills and ability to Perez's family.

Luna Perez v. Sturgis Public Schools

Cunningham "essentially invented the signing system she used" and her "command of sign language remained so poor that, when briefly paired with a different deaf student who used sign language, the other deaf student could not understand her at all." Perez had no way of knowing what was actually being said around him because he had no independent understanding of what was being said. Perez's parents further alleged that the aides were absent from class for hours on end. This was because, in 2015, Cunningham was given other duties away from Perez, leaving him with no means to communicate with others. It was alleged that he was learning nothing in his classes due to the absence of a qualified sign language interpreter. Perez was also excluded from the English Language Learner program from Sturgis extracurricular activities because he was deaf.

Luna Perez v. Sturgis Public Schools

Sturgis Schools misrepresented Perez's educational progress and academic achievement, awarding him inflated grades and advancing him no matter of his actual progress. He was given As and Bs in nearly every class and was on the Honor Roll every semester. His parents had assumed that he was on track to earn a high-school diploma. Just months before his graduation from high school with his class, he and his parents were informed he would not be awarded a high school diploma but a certificate of completion. This was because Perez was years behind where he should have been academically.

Luna Perez v. Sturgis Public Schools

Michigan Department of Education Administrative Complaint

In response to these revelations, Perez and his family filed an administrative complaint with the Michigan Department of Education. The complaint was filed in December 2017. The complaint alleged Sturgis denied him an adequate education and violated federal and state disability laws: the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), the Rehabilitation Act, and two Michigan disabilities laws. The complaint alleged that Sturgis Public Schools had failed to meet its requirements under the IDEA and did not provide Perez with Free and Appropriate Public Education (FAPE).

In June 2018 a written settlement offer was provided. Prior to hearing before the Department of Education, the Perez family and Sturgis Public Schools settled the IDEA/FAPE complaint. Sturgis Schools agreed to provide Perez with all the "forward-looking equitable relief he sought," including paying for Perez to at attended the Michigan School for the Deaf. The school also agreed to pay for "post-secondary compensatory education" and for sign language instruction for Perez and his family. It also paid the family's attorney's fees. The Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) dismissed the case and remaining claims in August 2018 with prejudice.

Federal District Court holding

Just months after the settlement and dismissal with prejudice in December 2018. Perez and his family filed a complaint in the United States District Court for the Western District of Michigan under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).

It was alleged the school discriminated against him by not providing the resources necessary for him to participate fully in class. Along with declaratory relief, Perez sought compensatory damages for his emotional distress.