_Freedom._--The treatment or "planning" of early printing--and generally of all pieces of lettering which are most pleasing--is strongly marked by _freedom_. This freedom of former times is frequently referred to now as "spontaneity"--sometimes it would seem to be implied that there was a lawless irresponsibility in the early craftsman, incompatible with modern conditions. True spontaneity, however, seems to come from _working by rule, but not being bound by it_.

For example, the old Herbal from which figs. 135 to 141 are taken contains many woodcuts of plants, &c., devoting a complete page to each. When a long explanation of a cut is required, _a smaller type is used_ (comp. figs. 135 & 138); when [p370] the explanation is very short, _it does not fill the page_. This is a free and natural treatment of the greatest convenience to the reader, for illustration and text are always in juxtaposition. And though the size of the type and the amount of the text are varied, yet the uniform top margins, and the uniform treatment and arrangement of the woodcuts, harmonise the pages, and give to the whole book an agreeable effect of freedom combined with method.

Writing & Illuminating, & Lettering — Part 147

_Diagram shewing arrangement of pages (about 1/7 size). Note: Inner columns of Commentary narrow (Text cols equal)_]

Writing & Illuminating, & Lettering — Part 147

An old way of treating a text and its commentary is indicated by the diagram (fig. 202). The text is printed in large type, the commentary, in smaller type, surrounds it; such portion of the text being printed on each page as will allow sufficient surrounding space for the accompanying [p371] commentary on that portion. The proportions and treatment of every page are uniform (note, particularly, the uniformity of the upper parts of the pages, five lines of commentary being allowed to enclose the text, or bound it above, on every page) with the exception that the height of the text-column varies--one page having as few as three lines of text to the column, another having fifty-nine lines. This free treatment of the text gives a charming variety to the pages.

Writing & Illuminating, & Lettering — Part 147

_Poetry._--A broader and freer treatment is desirable in the printing of poetry. The original lines and the arrangement of the verses should be more generally preserved. And though the opening lines of a poem may sometimes be magnified by printing them in capitals--which necessitate their division--to sacrifice the naturally varying line to the "even page" is questionable, and to destroy the form of a poem _in order to compress it_ is a "typographical impertinence" (see p. 95).