In spite of all this they knew Shevelin was not ripe for arrest. Finally, in a maudlin moment he conveyed the information that he had been the means of making a great achievement possible and that he had been treated very shabbily.
The detectives at once had the bank discharge him on some pretext foreign to the robbery. This added to Shevelin's gloom. When, on top of this, he was arrested, he was quite ripe to confess. That the gang might not become suspicious, he was arrested for intoxication, taken to court the next day, and discharged. As soon as he stepped out of the courtroom he was rearrested, and this procedure was repeated day after day.
Still Shevelin refused to confess until a detective, telling him how much the authorities knew about the case, informed him that all the gang were rich beyond measure except Shevelin.
"What a sucker you were, Pat," he concluded, "to accept a measly $10,000."
"It's a lie. I never got any $10,000, so help me heaven. I never got more than $600 for it."
"I apologize," said the detective, "you are a ten times bigger fool than any one supposed."
Shevelin realized he made a hopelessly damaging confession and within a few hours the police were in possession of the complete details of the case.
For fear anyone should not believe the actual amount that was taken from the bank, I refer you to the following official list of just what we got from the Manhattan Bank as it was announced by the president of the bank:
THE MANHATTAN SAVINGS INSTITUTION was, on the morning of Sunday, October 27, robbed of securities to the amount of $2,747,700, and $11,000 in cash, as follows:
United States 5's of 1881, 8 of $50,000 each, 10 of 10,000 each $500,000 United States 6's of 1881, 20 of $10,000 each 200,000 United States 10-40 bonds, 60 of 10,000 each 600,000 United States 4 per cents, 30 of $10,000 each 300,000 United States 5-20's of July, 1865; 26 of $500 each, 35 of $1,000 each 48,000 New York State sinking fund gold 6's, registered, No. 32 32,000 New York City Central Park fund stock, certificate No. 724 22,700 New York County Court House stock, 6 per cent. 202,000 New York City, accumulated debt, 7 per cent. bonds, two of $100,000 each, and one of $50,000 250,000 New York City Improvement stock, 10 certificates of $20,000 each 200,000 New York City Revenue Bond, registered 200,000 Yonkers City 7 per cent. coupon bonds, 118 of $1,000 each 118,000 Brooklyn City Water Loan coupon bonds, 25 of $1,000 each 25,000 East Chester Town coupon bonds, 50 of $1,000 each 50,000 Cash 11,000 ---------- Total amount stolen $2,758,700