Decision

Main text of the judgment

The judgment of prior instance and that of the first instance shall be quashed.

This case shall be remanded to the Wakayama District Court.

Judgement upon penal case of defamation, 1969-06-25

Reasons

As all the grounds of appeal submitted by Attorneys Atsushi Hashimoto and Shigeru Hosomi, including the one of alleged violation of Article 21 of the Constitution, are in substance no more than contentions of incorrectness in the construction and application of law, none of them amount to lawful grounds of a Jokoku appeal.

Judgement upon penal case of defamation, 1969-06-25

This Court, however, examines the case ex officio in view of the submissions. The gist of the facts constituting the offence indicated in the judgment of the court of first instance, and being affirmed by the court below is:

Judgement upon penal case of defamation, 1969-06-25

"The accused published in his paper 'The Yukan Wakayama Jiji' dated February 18, 1963 a news under the headline 'Wicked Acts of Tokuichiro Sakaguchi, the Blood-sucker' to the effect that Tokuichiro Sakaguchi, the proprietor of the Wakayama Tokudane Shimbun, or his subordinate under his instructions had given to a certain section chief in the Public Works Department of the Wakayama City Office within hearing of others a parting threat, 'If you made a due offer, we should shut our eyes to your deed. But as you are quite niggardly, you know what we shall do', and had threatened a certain higher superintendent of the City Office by making a remark, 'A tender feeling always finds a ready response, they say. Well, my boy, you are suspected of corruption, too. Shall we settle the matter over a glass in a proper place?' Wherewith the accused defamed Sakaguchi by alleging these facts in public."

The court of first instance applied in its judgment Paragraph 1 of Article 230 of the Penal Code to the above-mentioned facts and pronounced the accused guilty.

The attorneys in the court below contended, "Mens rea of defamation is negatived in the light of the fact that he believed in the existence of the facts he published on such information and grounds as to enable him to prove it. And the accused is not guilty " The court below rejected the contention in its judgment, saying, "It is the purport of the Decision of the Supreme Court (Decision of the 1st Petty Bench, May 7, 1969, Supreme Court Criminal Report Vol. 13, No. 5, p. 641) that the accused is not entitled to be exempted from criminal liability for defamation, notwithstanding his mistaken belief in the existence of the facts so long as it is not proved", and held that the accused could not be exempted from criminal liability for defamation, even if there had been good reason for his mistaken belief in the existence of the facts.

It should be observed, however, that Article 230-2 of the Penal Code has been enacted to reconcile the personal security to honour of an individual and the freedom of speech provided for in Article 21 of the Constitution. Giving thought to the reconciliation and balance of these two interests, it should be construed that, even if there is no proof of the existence of the facts under Paragraph 1 of Article 230-2 of the Penal Code, no crime of defamation was committed because of the absence of mens rea, when the publisher believed mistakenly in the existence of the facts and there was good reason for his mistaken belief on the basis of reliable information and grounds. We are of the opinion that the Decision of the Petty Bench of this Court (Decision of the 1st Petty Bench, May 7, 1959, Case Number (A) No. 2698 of 1958, Supreme Court Criminal Report Vol. 13 No. 5, p. 641) diverging from this construction and holding that the accused is not entitled to be exempted from criminal liability for defamation notwithstanding such mistaken belief so long as the existence of the facts is not proved, should be overruled. It follows that the aforementioned holding in the judgment of the court below is incorrect in the construction and application of law.