James Travis Laster is an American corporate lawyer and judge who has served as a Vice Chancellor of the Delaware Court of Chancery since 2009.
Legal career
Laster graduated from Princeton University in 1991 and the University of Virginia School of Law in 1995. He clerked for Judge Jane Richards Roth on the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, before working in private practice at the Delaware law firm Richards, Layton & Finger. He founded a boutique law firm, Abrams & Laster, in 2005.
Judicial career
In 2009, Governor Jack Markell nominated Laster to the Delaware Court of Chancery. He was confirmed by the Delaware Senate on September 22 and sworn in on October 9 for a 12-year term as Vice Chancellor. He took over the seat formerly held by Stephen P. Lamb.
He was nominated for a second term by Governor John Carney, and the Delaware Senate confirmed his reappointment on October 13, 2021.
Notable cases
In Akorn Inc. v. Fresenius Kabi AG, a 2018 mergers and acquisitions case, Laster's ruling was the first time that the court ever allowed a buyer to terminate a merger agreement based on a "material adverse effect" contract provision. Laster found that Akorn's business "fell off a cliff" after signing the agreement, and in a "durationally significant" way. He distinguished the case from other cases involving buyers who had "second thoughts after cyclical trends or industrywide effects negatively impacted their own businesses". He concluded that Fresenius was not required to close the deal and had validly terminated it. The Delaware Supreme Court affirmed.
In In re Delaware Public Schools Litigation, a 2020 lawsuit about property taxes and school funding, Laster ruled that all three Delaware counties' use of decades-old property values violated state law and the state constitution. The property tax system violated the state law requirement that property be assessed at "its true value in money", meaning fair market value, and the state constitution's requirement of uniform taxation. The litigation resulted in settlements, agreeing to property reassessments as well as school funding for certain disadvantaged students.
In United Food & Commercial Workers Union v. Zuckerberg, a 2020 lawsuit challenging the approval by the board of directors of Facebook, Inc. of a stock reclassification plan, Vice Chancellor Laster proposed a "refined test" for assessing whether a stockholder derivative plaintiff has satisfied the heightened pleading standards of Court of Chancery Rule 23.1. In a derivative suit, a stockholder plaintiff who meets the requirements of Rule 23.1 causes the corporation to bring a lawsuit against someone who has harmed the corporation, usually a corporate insider. Derivative suits thus "play an important role in policing corporate insider conduct and compliance by directors and controlling stockholders with their fiduciary duties." Rule 23.1 requires that a would-be derivative plaintiff either first demand that the board of directors cause the corporation to bring the lawsuit or plead "with particularity" that the directors could not have impartially considered a litigation demand—for example, if a majority of the board would be liable for the alleged misconduct that is the subject of the derivative lawsuit. In Zuckerberg, Vice Chancellor Laster proposed a new test for derivative actions that "blended" two overlapping standards "into a modern three-part test that accounts for recent developments in Delaware corporation law." In 2021, the Delaware Supreme Court unanimously approved the use of Laster's proposed test as the "universal test" for demand futility.