It was in the search for such pairs of stars that the _Catalogue of Double Stars_ (1782) was formed. HERSCHEL'S first idea of a double star made such pairs as he found, to consist of two stars _accidentally_ near to each other. A was near to us, and appeared projected in a certain place on the celestial sphere. B was many times more distant, but, by chance, was seen along the same line, and made with A an _optical_ double. If the two stars were at the same distance from the earth, if they made part of the same physical system, if one revolved around the other, then this method of gaining a knowledge of their distance failed. Even in his first memoir on the subject, a surmise that this latter state might occur in some cases, was expressed by HERSCHEL. The notes on some of the pairs declare that a motion of one of them was suspected. But this motion might be truly orbital--of one star about the other as a centre--or it might simply be that one star was moving by its own _proper_ motion, and leaving the other behind. It was best to wait and see. The first Catalogue of Double Stars contained two hundred and three instances of such associations. These were observed from time to time, and new pairs discovered. The paper of MICHELL, "An Inquiry into the probable Parallax and Magnitude of the Fixed Stars, from the Quantity of Light which they Afford, and the Particular Circumstances of their Situation" (1767), was read and pondered. By 1802 HERSCHEL had become certain that there existed in the heavens real pairs of stars, both at the same distance from the earth, which were physically connected with each other. The arguments of MICHELL have been applied by BESSEL to the case of one of HERSCHEL'S double stars, in much the same order in which the argument ran in HERSCHEL'S own mind, as follows:
The star _Castor_ (_[alpha] Geminorum_) is a double star, where A is of the second, and B of the fourth, magnitude. To the naked eye these two appear as one star. With a telescope this is seen to be two stars, some 5" apart. In the whole sky there are not above fifty such stars as the brighter of the two, and about four hundred of the brilliancy of B. These fifty and four hundred stars are scattered over the vault of heaven, almost at random. No law has yet been traced by which we can say that here or here there shall be a bright star like A, or a fainter one like B. In general the distribution appears to be fortuitous. How then can we account for one of the four hundred stars like B placed so close to one of the fifty like A?